Working with employment agencies is often part of the hiring process when you’re responsible for staffing a law office. Whether you’re bringing on temporary help or searching for permanent team members, negotiating well with agencies is key to finding the right people at the right price. This guide will help you approach those conversations with confidence and strategy.
1. Understand Your Needs Before You Start
Before you even contact an employment agency, take some time to clearly define what your law office needs. Are you looking for temporary paralegals, long-term administrative assistants, or specialized legal researchers? Understanding the specifics of your requirements will enable you to communicate effectively with the agency and ensure they provide candidates who meet your standards.
2. Do Your Research
Knowledge is power in any negotiation. Research the going rates for the roles you’re looking to fill, both in your local area and within the legal industry. Additionally, familiarize yourself with the reputation of various employment agencies. Knowing which agencies are known for quality placements can give you leverage in negotiations, as you’ll be able to align with partners who have a track record of success.
3. Discuss Fees Upfront
Employment agencies often have set fees for their services, but these fees are not always set in stone. Be upfront about your budget and see if there’s any flexibility in their rates. It’s also worth asking about any additional charges that might not be immediately apparent, such as fees for background checks or skills testing. Ensure everything is clearly laid out in the contract to avoid any unexpected costs down the line.
4. Negotiate on the Quality of Candidates
While cost is important, the quality of the candidates you receive should be a top priority. In your discussions with the agency, make it clear that you’re looking for high-caliber candidates and that you’re willing to discuss terms that reflect that need. You might negotiate to have a trial period with a candidate where you can assess their fit for the role before fully committing.
5. Leverage Your Relationship
If you have an ongoing relationship with an employment agency, use that to your advantage. Long-term partnerships can lead to better deals, as agencies value repeat business. Remind them of the successful placements they’ve made in the past and express your interest in continuing to work together—this can give you additional leverage in negotiations.
6. Consider Volume Discounts
If you’re hiring for multiple positions or foresee a need for several placements over time, inquire about volume discounts. Employment agencies may be willing to reduce their fees if you commit to using their services for multiple hires. This can be particularly beneficial for larger law firms or during times of expansion.
7. Negotiate Contract Terms
In addition to fees and candidate quality, don’t forget to negotiate the terms of your contract. This includes aspects like the duration of the agency’s exclusivity, the replacement guarantee period if a hire doesn’t work out, and the payment schedule. Ensure the contract protects your law office’s interests and offers some flexibility in case circumstances change.
8. Stay Professional and Assertive
Throughout the negotiation process, maintain a professional and assertive demeanor. Be clear about your expectations and don’t hesitate to push back if something doesn’t align with your needs. However, also be open to compromise—negotiation is a two-way street, and finding a middle ground that satisfies both parties is often the key to a successful agreement.
9. Review the Final Agreement Carefully
Once you’ve negotiated the terms, take the time to thoroughly review the final agreement before signing. Ensure all verbal agreements are included in writing, and double-check the fine print for any clauses that might have been overlooked. This final step can save your law office from potential issues down the road.
Negotiating with employment agencies doesn’t have to be daunting. By preparing thoroughly, communicating clearly, and maintaining a professional stance, you can secure the best possible terms for your law office. Remember, the goal is to build a mutually beneficial partnership that helps you find the right talent to support your firm’s success.

