• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • LOGIN
  • Law Office ManagerHOME
  • Book StoreBook Store
  • WebinarsWebinars
  • LOGIN
  • Manage Your Account
  •  
Law Office Manager

Law Office Manager

  • Hiring
  • Increasing profits
  • Technology
  • Billing
  • Managing staff
  • More! ⇩
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Time tracking
    • Client relations
    • Termination
    • Tool Box
    • Risk management
    • Recordkeeping
    • Cartoons
    • Reader tips
    • Purchasing & leasing
    • Marketing
    • Managing the office
    • Information security
    • Your career
    • Working with lawyers
    • Employee benefits
    • Compliance
    • Workplace Safety
  • Special Reports

Your interview notes could get you in trouble

November 26, 2023

By Dr. Steve M. Cohen  bio

Although workforce disasters usually make the headlines, there are a number of “basic” human resource tasks that should not be discounted. One is the job candidate interview.

Theoretically, interviews should not be a problem. They’re a common occurrence, with no possible traps, right? After all, the candidate just wants the job and you are making the decision.

While you are indeed in charge, an interviewee may not only come back on you, but may have even planned to come back on you when he or she doesn’t get the job.

Before we go any further, be aware that there are three kinds of behavior: overt, inadvertent, and opportunistic. It’s the last one that matters here. Opportunistic behavior can also be called predatory in that the individual sees an opportunity to take advantage of someone and then does. An interview can be the breeding ground for this behavior.

Picture this scenario. You are interviewing someone and the candidate offers the information that he or she is a single parent with four children, all under the age of five. You did not ask anything that would warrant or require that information because, as a law-abiding manager, you know it’s illegal to ask for marital or dependency information according to the Department of Labor (DOL). But at some point in the interview, this information was offered and, worse yet, you put it in your notes.

That’s a big problem. Whether you purposefully or accidentally included it in the interview notes, and even if you didn’t use that information to decide on employment, the interviewee can accuse you of discriminatory behavior if he or she does not get the job.

In our hypothetical case, the candidate returns after not getting the job and they bring legal counsel. You swear the information had nothing to do with your employment decision. But no matter what you say, the opportunistic interviewee and their legal counsel will assert that it was important enough to be notated. You and your company have been nailed.

This sort of assertion is worth a costly settlement to avoid a nuisance suit.

There are even individuals who pull this stunt four or five times a year on inexperienced interviewers. This is opportunistic behavior in its most glaring light. Watch for it.

Be ready for the interview. Make sure you are only asking legal questions and writing down information that is directly relevant and material to the job. As an interviewer, carefully plan your interview with previously prepared questions for the candidates to answer. Consciously discredit any unavoidable chit-chat or unsolicited information. Only take notes that matter—responses to your DOL-approved questions.

Stick to that script and you will be safe.

Dr. Steve M. Cohen is Principal and Lead HR Consultant at HR Solutions: On Call, an advisory service for medical practices and other small businesses.

Filed Under: Hiring, Compliance, articles, Available for NL Tagged With: Compliance, Risk management, Hiring

Primary Sidebar

Free Reports

    • Guide to Advanced Hiring Techniques
    • Employee Morale in the Law Office
    • Workplace Bullying

Free Premium Reports

    • 7 Smart Cost-Cutting Strategies for Your Law Office
    • Guide to Advanced Hiring Techniques
    • Employee Morale in the Law Office
    • Workplace Bullying
    • 7 Proven Ways to Make Your Billing and Collections More Profitable
    • 7 Simple, Proven Steps to Hiring the Right Staff
    • 7 Policies Every Law Office Should Have

Download Current Issue

Current Issue

Recent Headlines

Billing: Should You Keep It In-House or Go Outsourced?

Year-End Reflections: Taking Stock of Your Law Office’s Successes and Challenges

Winter Safety Checklist for Parking Lots, Walkways, and Office Entrances

January To-Do List for a Busy Law Office Manager

Want to Work Smarter, Not Harder? AI Can Help You Do Just That

Your Career

Year-End Reflections: Taking Stock of Your Law Office’s Successes and Challenges

Want to Work Smarter, Not Harder? AI Can Help You Do Just That

Administrator a Key Player in Firm’s Ethics and Integrity

Reconnecting with Purpose: How to Invite Someone from the Past into Your Career Network

To Make a Point, Use the Body Language that Supports Your Words

Deliver Your Message

Footer

Return to the Top

Download the Current issue
Monthly Magazine Archive
Advertise in Law Office Manager
Download Media Kit

Become a Premium Member
Download a Sample Issue of LOM
Renew your Law Office Manager Membership
Manage Your Account
Contact Law Office Manager
About Law Office Manager
Terms & Conditions
Privacy Policy
Give Us Feedback


Copyright © 2025 Plain Language Media, LLLP • 1-888-729-2315